Toy cleaner is the twelve dollar purchase that decides whether a hundred dollar toy lasts five years or one. It is also a category where the products genuinely differ, mostly in format rather than chemistry, and the right one depends entirely on what you own.
Soap and water versus dedicated cleaner
Plain unscented soap and warm water genuinely cleans nonporous materials. Silicone, glass, steel and ABS plastic can all be cleaned that way, and for those materials a dedicated cleaner is convenience rather than necessity.
Where it stops being optional:
- Porous materials. TPE, TPR and soft strokers have a structure that surface washing does not reach. An antibacterial cleaner is doing real work here.
- Textured internals. Ribs, spirals and chambers hold residue. A foaming cleaner expands into them; liquid runs past.
- Motorised toys. You cannot submerge them, so a spray you can wipe off is the practical option.
- Anything shared. Between partners, the margin for thoroughness matters more.
The picks
All Spicerack Selects, our in house shop, free discreet shipping.
Toy Cleaners: Free Discreet Shipping
SpicerackSelects
Wicked Cleene, twelve dollars, the default
Antibacterial spray, unscented, safe on every material we sell. If you buy one bottle, buy this and keep it in the drawer rather than the bathroom.
Wicked Simply Cleene, thirteen dollars
Same job, shorter ingredient list. The pick for sensitive skin or if fragrance bothers you.
Wicked Foam n Fresh, sixteen dollars
Foaming rather than liquid, which is the only format that properly reaches textured internals. If you own a stroker, this is the one.
pjur Toy Clean, eighteen dollars
Alcohol free and safe on silicone, with Pjur’s characteristically clinical approach.
La Nua Foaming, twenty eight dollars
Larger foaming format for people with enough toys that small bottles became annoying.
Wicked Refill, 24oz, thirty dollars
Cheapest per use here by a wide margin. Buy this once you know you will keep using it.
What to avoid
Rubbing alcohol on silicone. Fine on glass and steel, degrades silicone over time.
Antibacterial hand soap. Harsher than needed and often fragranced, which irritates.
Boiling anything with a motor. Obvious, still happens.
Dishwasher for anything but motorless silicone, glass or steel. Top rack, no detergent, and only those three.
The routine
- Clean immediately after use, before anything dries.
- Warm water rather than hot on anything with electronics.
- Pay attention to seams and texture, which is where residue actually hides.
- Dry completely before storing, and check charge ports are dry before plugging in.
- Store silicone separately, since silicone against silicone can react.
Full material by material detail in our cleaning guide, and storage in our storage guide.
FAQ
Do I need cleaner if only I use the toy? Yes. Bacteria and yeast do not require a second person.
How often should I replace a porous toy? At the first sign of tackiness, cloudiness, or a smell that survives washing.
Is spray or foam better? Spray for smooth surfaces, foam for anything textured or internal.
Browse all toy care.
More Toy Care
