Spicerack Collection
butt plugs
Discover the perfect mix of comfort and stimulation with butt plugs designed for beginners, pros, and everyone in between.
Search Filters
Discreet Billing & Shipping
Buyer Protection
US-Based Fast Shipping
425+ Indie Artisans
Door Stopper Butt Plug! Medium, Stainless Steel, FUN, Novelty Gag Gift!
GlowFuckyourself
5.0 (6)
$35.00
The Original Booty Bong! Small, Stainless-Steel and Glow in the Dark, Ready for LOVE!
GlowFuckyourself
$40.00
You Shall Not Pass! Butt Plug – Handmade Gandalf the Grey Figure - Free EU Shipping
Made in Invernalia
$45.00
Chrysolite Austrian Crystal Decorated Rose Gold Butt Plug · Erotic Insertable Sex Toy for Women · Anal Trainer Kit Christmas Gift
Krystail Intimate Jewelry
$88.00
You Shall Not Pass! Butt Plug – Handmade Polymer Clay - Free EU Shipping
Made in Invernalia
$38.00
Uldred's Egg - Signature Color - Custom Fantasy Butt Plug - Silicone Plug Sex Toy
Kreature Toys
$53.99
Related Searches
Four-star and five-star reviews from customers who were delighted with their Spicerack finds.
Heath
Mar 2026
“Exactly what I wanted. Only downside is that when you pluck it it doesn't make the noise door stoppers usually do”
Door Stopper Butt Plug! Medium, Stainless Steel, FUN, Novelty Gag Gift!
YummyZest6c98c
Verified buyer · Mar 2025
“Got a medium plug which is a bit on the large side but still not difficult to work with. This is one of the most comfortable plugs I've had. The neck is just long enough that the bulb sits comfortably and the T-bar is...”
Comfy and Beautiful Silicone Butt Plug
Spicerack customer
Verified buyer · Sep 2024
“Twisted Mountain Toys makes some of the best adult toys I have ever seen and used. The stretched Extended Wear Silicone Butt Plug (1XL "Ooof") is somehow both huge but insertable, and it feels good enough to wear for...”
Stretched Extended Wear Silicone Butt Plug
SauceSavvydcd3f
Verified buyer · Apr 2026
“This was a long shot because Nicky at the time didn't post to Australia, but a message and quick conversation about expenses and we were on track. the process of ordering was straight forward and Nicky was...”
Butt Plug Two Set with chain. Pop them in & join your partner.Two Butt Plug set (Any combination of Small, Medium or Large) which you design the base.
Spicerack customer
Verified buyer · May 2026
“Extremely high quality and super comfortable. Can be worn for very long time and absolutely no way you can push it out, even if the straps are not very tight. Have it in red.”
Muzzle Harness Gag. Bolt-Thru Silicone Ball. Genuine Leather.
CinnamonSwirlf433a
Verified buyer · May 2026
“Fantastic work as always, super comfy, thank you!”
Premium Utility Leather Wrist Cuffs - BDSM
CinnamonSwirlf433a
Verified buyer · May 2026
“Amazing quality, thank you!”
Medium Leash / Lead - Biothane - BDSM
SteamySpice29aa6
Verified buyer · Apr 2026
“Wow! Even better than expected, the leather is very nice and soft, thank you!”
Dragon cane set. 3 different thicknesses, rattan BDSM canes - whippy dragon, medium dragon and chunky dragon cane.
TwistedFlavor08a5a
Verified buyer · Mar 2026
“Exactly as described, versatile and easy to use”
Twisted Adjustable Nipple Clamps
Find Your Perfect Fetish Fit
Let's find your perfect match
